A Review of Critical Essays on Jane Eyre written by Carla Kaplan and Kelly Marsh
For my CMP 125 class, we were asked to review the essays we considered the most helpful and the least helpful to our understanding of the Jane Eyre novel among those in the Norton Critical Edition. Here is my submission.
Most helpful: Carla Kaplan’s “Girl Talk: Jane Eyre and the Romance of Women’s Narration”.
In “Girl Talk: Jane Eyre and the Romance of Women’s Narration,” Carla Kaplan argues that, although Jane is looking for someone to whom she can narrate her story, she is unable to find anyone capable of being her listener, hence she chooses to narrate to a future reader in the hope they will understand her. The author quotes that even if any language is dialogic (meaning that all statements derive their meaning from context), there is no guarantee that the conversation in which it is deployed will be mutually, let alone equally-beneficial to its participants. The author observes that in the opening passages of Jane Eyre, Jane is excluded from conversations and group activities, yet she holds a resolve to “Speak I must.” Kaplan, speaking in terms of Jane’s “passion,” refers to this desire to speak, and be heard, as an eroticism of talk.
Kaplan further observes that Jane measures her relationships with a yardstick of narrative exchange. ‘Conversation is the “paradise of union” to which Jane aspires’ the author remarks. However, Jane’s promise to tell her story to anyone who asks is hampered by the fact that hardly anyone asks, and even when someone asks, they fail to understand her. In order to demonstrate this, Kaplan provides scenarios where, when Jane is asked for her story, her “listeners” don’t understand her or require external confirmation to believe her: Mr. Lloyd, Helen Burns, and Miss Temple. She also notes that on multiple occasions Jane is regarded as a better listener than a narrator by both Rochester and St. John. She unmasks a surprising detail in the book: Jane’s account of the first time she derived “unusual pleasure” partaking in a conversation was with the Rivers’ sisters, and not with Rochester although, speaking of him she says, “while I breathe and think, I must love him.” Kaplan implies that adult Jane Eyre’s choice to write about her experience is a way of seeking sisterhood and people with whom she can engage in “girl talk” in a fulfilling way.
Least helpful: Kelly Marsh’s “Jane Eyre and the Pursuit of the Mother’s Pleasure”
In “Jane Eyre and the Pursuit of the Mother’s Pleasure,” Kelly Marsh argues that Jane, through her decisions, is in a quest to discover her mother’s story and “to discover in her mother’s story her mother’s pleasure.” The author tells us that while it may not seem as though Jane is interested in any history beyond her own, not even that of her parents,’ “the past is very much with Jane.” By way of proof, she asserts that Jane is, over the course of the novel, re-living the experiences of her mother. Using Jane’s encounter with Rochester after her return to Thornfield, his remark that Jane “comes from the abode of people who are dead,” her early life at Gateshead: the site of Mr. and Mrs. Reed’s deaths, her eight years at Lowood: the site of multiple children’s deaths, and her return to Ferndean from Thornfield: the site of Bertha Mason’s death, the author insinuates (in not so clear terms) that these experiences tell us (and Jane) more about her mother.
It is important to note that, Marsh believes that Jane needs to know her mother’s story and not that of her father because “the one story the mother possesses uniquely is always the true story of the conception of her child” implying that a mother is the only one who knows the true father of a child, irrespective of who others (including the supposed father) may think it is. The author suggests that Jane’s desire for a relationship with Rochester is because of an incest fetish she harbors within her.
Marsh goes on to suggest that Jane’s mother, through visions, helps convince her to leave Gateshead, and later, Thornfield. The author argues that Jane’s experience “mothering” Adele is akin to her mother’s experience with her: short, passionate and ends with the child sent to school.
The author does not acknowledge Jane Reed did not send off Jane Eyre, she died while baby Jane was in her custody and only then, did her brother assume ownership over the child. The author, further extrapolating her point, contends that Jane’s relationship with Rochester is similar in intensity to the love that her mother had for her father. Both stuck to the men they chose, irrespective of how challenging that might have been. The author concludes by reiterating that Jane Eyre has by her experiences, learned of her mother’s story and “found it legitimizing.” I may be wrong, but the essay feels to me as wishful thinking and a search for shadows.