Imaa Minifax
← All writing

A Paper on Jane Eyre: "Jane Eyre: Religion as Source"

For my CMP 125 class, we wrote a paper on Jane Eyre that used specific details to prove our point. Here's the paper I wrote.

For this paper, my point is that Jane Eyre is religious, in a different way. She is religious, but not for public approval or praise. I argue that Jane Eyre is religious in a way that’s honest to her, and not pious.

Introduction

At every difficult situation in Jane’s life, she appeals to something beyond her desire, a religious standard. In this paper, I argue that religion served as the source of Jane’s principles: it gave her a conscience she answers to, a law to uphold, and a way to discern being religious from believing in God. Throughout her life, Jane strongly rejects religion as it was presented to her. She rejects Brocklehurst’s sanctimony, Helen’s passivity, and St. John’s proposed God-ordained marriage. Religion to Jane was not about performing to be approved, it was about keeping a pure conscience.

Jane’s formative encounter with religion was at Lowood where she meets Helen Burns. The word “Helen” is believed to have originated from the Greek language, and it means “light” or “shining one.” It cannot be random that Charlotte Bronte chooses to name the character who changes Jane’s life a name that implies a light shining so brightly it burns. After Jane is called a liar and ridiculed before the whole school, Helen tells her that if all the world hated her, and believed her wicked, while her own conscience approved of her and absolved her from guilt, she would not be without friends. We will see this play out over the course of Jane’s life where on multiple occasions, she chooses to maintain a pure conscience, over what anyone may have taught. Interestingly, Jane did not accept all of Helen’s teachings. She maintains her stance that when people strike us, we should retaliate as a form of retribution and lesson. As a 10-year-old, she took what part of Helen’s philosophy she thought was right and discarded the rest. We will see her do more of this as she grows.

Although Jane was religious in her own way, it is telling observing the things she refuses to take from others’ religiousness. Brocklehurst approached Christianity as a tool to instill fear and exert control. When he asks her how she would avoid hell, knowing her answer could come off as rude and objectionable, she tells him she must keep in good health and not die. When he asks if she liked the psalms, she says very directly that she did not. When compared with the little boy who would rather read a Psalm than eat, and wanted to be an angel, she again states very directly she has no intention of being an angel and wants to be herself. We see this repeat itself with Rochester; when he calls her an angel, and she tells him plainly, she is not an angel and will never be one till she dies. Both times Jane declines the appearance of being saintly. She believes in God but won’t appear pious for public approval.

We come across Jane’s most decisive moment after the wedding was called off. Although Jane loved Rochester so intensely she describes herself as mad, she chooses to heed the principles and law given by God. She loved him and wanted to be more than a mistress to him. During her conversation with Rochester, she says “I will keep the law given by God; sanctioned by man. I will hold to the principles received by me when I was sane, and not mad—as I am now.” Jane knows very clearly that what she wants was different from what she believes, and she chose to go with what she believes. Explaining why, she says “Laws and principles are not for the times when there is no temptation: they are for such moments as this, when body and soul rise in mutiny against their rigour; stringent are they; inviolate they shall be. If at my individual convenience I might break them, what would be their worth? They have a worth—so I have always believed…” implying that a principle she would break for personal convenience has no worth. That night she dreams of a white human form telling her to flee temptation, to which she affirms she will. This event reflects a verse in the Bible, 1 Corinthians 10:13 where the Apostle Paul reassures believers that when faced with temptation, God will always provide a way out. For Jane, the way out could be seen as the dream she had where she was told what step to take next. That was her last night at Thornfield. Although the world, in the form of Rochester, does not approve, her conscience does. Hence why she was later elated, when pondering on the choice to leave Rochester, that she never gave in to becoming his mistress, but chose instead to venture into the unknown.

Unlike others who may have cared about appearance, Jane’s loyalty remained to her conscience, not someone religious. After St. John asks her to marry him, as God’s instruction for her life, and join him on a missionary journey to India, Jane agrees to go, but not as his wife. Again, she chooses to question a religious belief. St. John believes God’s will to be superior, and Jane believes marriage as a union should be between two people who love each other. When these beliefs clashed, Jane refuses to submit to his view. Helen, Brocklehurst and now St. John were all religious, yet Jane questioned their religious beliefs, although she believed in the same God they all believed in.

Conclusion

By the end of the book, Jane had stuck to maintaining a conscience that approved of her even when people around her may not have agreed. She returns to Rochester, after he becomes a widower, but not as his mistress. In the book, religion was not just a casual activity for Jane Eyre, it was the source of her principles even when love, fear and ambition tried to break her resolve. Although she stuck to those principles all through the story, she never performed for public approval. Bronte ends the novel with St. John’s hope of Heaven, which suggests the book may be as much about religion as about anything else.

Works Cited

Bronte, Charlotte. Jane Eyre. Edited by Deborah Lutz, Fourth Norton Critical Edition, 2016. “Helen (given name).” Wikipedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 30 Sept. 2026, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helen_(given_name). Accessed 11 Oct. 2026.